Saturday, April 20, 2024

Hamilton cop says something was ‘off about the bathroom’ in the Holly Hamilton murder trial

First Published:

The mother of a 29-year-old woman who was murdered in Hamilton in 2018 testified on Wednesday in the murder trial of her daughter’s accused killer.

Justin Dumpfrey has pleaded not guilty to the second-degree murder of Holly Hamilton.

Hamilton’s body was found inside the trunk of her work vehicle on Jan. 17, three days after she was last seen by family. The young mother had been stabbed 17 times in the face, neck and torso.

Dumpfrey and Hamilton had been in an on-again, off-again relationship and shared a young child.

Hamilton’s mother, Angela, told the court that she had initially approved of her daughter’s relationship with Dumpfrey but her opinion changed after a few months when she became aware that her daughter was being abused.

“When she became pregnant, that’s when things started getting out of control,” Angela said.

The court heard Hamilton’s townhome had been broken into a few weeks before her death and the 29-year-old believed it was Dumpfrey.

Angela said her daughter was so shaken up that she talked about moving to Ottawa to get away from him.

During cross-examination, Dumpfrey’s lawyer, John Erickson, questioned Hamilton’s fear of his client. Erickson asked Stacie, Hamilton’s sister, about a video that appeared to be shot by Dumpfrey and showed Hamilton joking around at the beach with their daughter.

Stacie said the laughter may have been genuine but it also could have been a facade for the benefit of their child who was just a few feet away in the video.

RELATED STORY: Holly Hamilton’s sister takes the stand in second-degree murder trial

The court also heard from the Hamilton police officer who was ordered to go into Dumpfrey’s apartment on Jan. 15 after he left his four-year-old daughter on the doorstep of her grandmother’s house.

Cst. Ben Kingdom said he knocked on the door of Dumpfrey’s apartment on Barton St. near Fairfield Ave. but no one answered. He then entered the empty apartment through an open window and noted a light left on in the bathroom.

“The rest of the apartment was incredibly messy but the bathroom was spotless,” Kingdom said.

He told the court officers later found a grocery store receipt that included supplies like bleach and garbage bags, none of which were located in the apartment.

The trial continues Thursday.

More Top News

Students, parents at Westdale school protest start time change

It's been two years since the start bell time changed from 8:35 a.m. to 8 a.m. at Westdale Secondary. A group of parents and...

Ontario’s Big City Mayors discuss housing, mental health and homelessness

Ontario's Big City Mayors held its annual general meeting in downtown Burlington on Friday, with Mayor Marianne Meed Ward chairing the event.  The meeting focused...

Evening weather forecast for April 19, 2024

Shelly Marriage breaks down the forecast for April 19, 2024 and the weekend ahead.

Sportsline: Allan Cup Challenge tournament director Don Robertson

VIDEO: Canada's oldest national hockey championship, the Allan Cup Challenge, begins Saturday in Dundas. On April 27, the final will be televised on CHCH...

Hamilton police report 26% increase in hate-related incidents in 2023

Hate in Hamilton is on the rise, according to figures pulled from the city's latest police report. On Friday, the force said it recorded 220...

Gas line struck after stolen car crashes into Hamilton home

A stolen pickup truck crashed into other vehicles then two houses in east Hamilton rupturing their natural gas lines early Friday. Police called on residents...