LATEST STORIES:

Bantleman trial: “a good day for our defence”

Make us a preferred source on Google
Share this story...

(Updated) A second accuser took the stand as Burlington teacher Neil Bantleman’s trial on child sexual abuse allegations at an Indonesian school entered its second day.

Canadian and British diplomats were not allowed in the courtroom; only the three judges presiding over the case, court staff, lawyers and those directly involved are allowed in. Even though a diplomat from the British embassy acquired the proper paperwork to go inside earlier in the trial, he was denied access today due to Indonesian law governing child sex assault cases.

During a six hour session today, a boy and his mother testified through teleconference; the father testified in court. According to Bantleman’s wife Tracy, the alleged victim was looking to his mother for confirmation; she added his testimony was inconsistent.

The boy said the perpetrator has a skeleton tattoo which Tracy says Neil does not have. According to Bantleman the boy also had a difficult time identifying where the alleged assault took place.

Tracy spoke with CHCH News earlier this morning. She said Neil was under a great deal of stress the night before as he was waiting to find out which witnesses would be testifying.

“Preparing for trial, being prepared in case you’re asked any questions or given the opportunity to ask, it’s helpful to know who will be appearing in court. He hasn’t really had frequent access to his lawyers because the location of the jail is quite far out of the city centre and so he’s been quite stressed.”

“But after today I did see him smiling and (co-accused Ferdinand Tijong) smiling, they seemed to be more relieved by today’s testimony because it was so inconsistent. The father was so confrontational in the courtroom that they felt that it was a good day for our defence overall.”

According to Bantleman’s family, no physical evidence of sexual assault has been put before the courts. Over 100 parents, students and staff from the Jakarta International School gathered outside the court room today.

Tracy says her husband is hopeful he will be declared not guilty. 5 janitors at the same school have already been sentenced to up to 8 years in jail in a similar sexual assault trial involving one of the same victims, a 6 year old boy.

Additional video: CHCH’s Tim Bolen talks to Tracy Bantleman about day 2 of the trial

Transcript:

Tim Bolen, CHCH News: A Burlington man was back in an Indonesia court today as his trial on sexual abuse allegations at a Jakarta school continues. His wife Tracy joins us live by phone with an update. Tracy, thanks for joining us once again. I’m reading here that the hearing lasted over 6 hours today. Can you tell us about today’s proceedings?
TB: “Yes. Today to start out, the Canadian and British embassies were present in the courtroom and they tried to gain access them were denied access despite the British embassy having paperwork. Soon after the trial started there was one alleged victim with his mother who testified through teleconference and in the afternoon the father of the child also testified.”

CHCH: Quickly back to the Canadian and British embassies denied access. It says the Canadian embassy did not have paperwork in place. Do you know why is that the case?
TB: “No, and it seems as though, you know, both embassies have been working together to try to determine the best method of gaining access to the courtroom. They seem to be getting a little bit of a runaround in regard to gaining access to the trial, but they continue to try working at all levels to gain access to ensure a transparent trial.”

CHCH: OK so back to the boy and his mother testifying for over 2 hours. What was the response from the defence lawyers on the testimony?
TB: “Well for the boy’s testimony it was reported that the boy consistently looked to his mother for confirmation of his thought throughout the session. His testimony was inconsistent and illogical. Apparently the child said the alleged perpetrator has a skeleton tattoo which neither my husband or Ferdi (co-accused Ferdinand Tijong) has.”

“He had difficulty clearly identifying the location for the alleged assault and the father in the afternoon was apparently quite confrontational in the courtroom. He attempted to take command of the court to tell his story. The judges had to reprimanded him for not following the rules of the court and answering directly a yes/no reply.”

“One of the things we have been concerned about from the beginning is the suggestive nature of questioning that the parents might have taken on in dealing with their children when these allegations first came forward by a first mother back in March of 2014.”

CHCH: How is your feeling, and the defence lawyers thus far with how the court is portraying this case? Do you fell it’s been a fair trial thus far?
TB: “Well, I do believe from what I have heard based on my being able to only sit in on one session that is was the reading of the exception, and from hearing from our lawyers is that the judge is wanting to have a very fair trial based on Indonesian law and respecting international law. She actually stated that earlier on in the trial.”

“We are getting a sense that at this level of court she is doing her best to create a session and a trial that runs smoothly and succinctly and also timely, in a timely fashion, so I am feeling at least at that level that is happening.”

CHCH: We are looking at pictures of you with Neil. How is Neil doing?
TB: “You know it wasn’t until actually late last night that we found out which witness would testify today and that did cause my husband a great deal of anxiety. As you can imagine preparing for trial, being prepared in case you’re asked any questions or given the opportunity to ask, it’s helpful to know who will be appearing in court. He hasn’t really had frequent access to his lawyers because the location of the jail is quite far out of the city centre and so he’s been quite stressed.”

“But after today I did see him smiling and Ferdi smiling, they seemed to be more relieved by today’s testimony because it was so inconsistent. The father was so confrontational in the courtroom that they felt that it was a good day for our defence overall.”

CHCH: Tracy, we thank you for the update. Thoughts and prayers continue to flood in from here in Canada and to you and to Neil and the entire family, and we hope you continue to update us on the situation.
TB: “Absolutely. Thanks, Tim.”