LATEST STORIES:

Inquest: Smith death a homicide

Make us a preferred source on Google
Share this story...

(Update)

 

A coroner’s jury has decided that the death of a 19-year old woman who choked herself inside a women’s prison in Kitchener was a homicide, not a suicide.

Ashley Smith died as prison guards stood by. They were ordered by senior management not to help her. Now, the laywer representing Smith’s family says a criminal investigation into her death should be reopened. We should note that a verdict of homicide in an inquest setting is not one of *legal responsibility*, rather it’s a finding that another person contributed to Smith’s death.

Thursday’s decision comes six years after Smith died.

A gasp could be heard throughout the coroner’s courtroom when the verdict of homicide was read aloud. But for those who have been working to find justice for Smith, The fight isn’t over yet.

The verdict by the jury, the ruling that it’s a homicide is a clear statement that those in charge caused Ashley’s death.

On behalf of Ashley Smith’s family, lawyer Julian Falconer called for police to reopen the investigation into those who ordered prison guards not to enter Smith’s cell as long as she was breathing. Smith died in October 2007 when she tied a ligature around her neck, which she did frequently, as guards watched. But Falconer says there is no need to reopen the criminal case against the front line prison staff: “The deputy warden, the warden those above have yet to truly be investigated or yet to truly answer for their actions.”

The all-female jury heard from 83 witnesses over the course of the 11 month inquest. Among other video documenting Smith’s time in the federal system, the jury watched footage of Smith aboard a plane during a prison transfer with her hands and wrists duct taped to the seat. The jury made over 100 recommendations for preventing future deaths under similar circumstances. Among them, they’re recommending that’s Smith’s case be used as a case study for all staff and management of correctional service of Canada.”

They also recommended that seriously mentally ill women serve time in federal treatment facilities instead of prisons. That all female inmates be assessed by a psychologist within 3 days of being admitted. And that prison staff be allowed to refuse orders without fear of discipline if they have an ethical or legal objection.

Jason Godin is National V.P. Of the Union of Canadian Correctional Officers: “Those orders essentially prevented our members from doing their job. So many of the recommendations by the jury we’re not surprised by. And we’re in favour of many of these recommendations.”

The jury also suggested female inmates be accommodated in the region closest to their family and social supports. In the 11 months leading up to her death, Smith was transferred 17 times between nine institutions.

Smith was 15-years old the first time she went to jail. She was given a 90-day sentence for throwing crab apples at a postal worker. But she was kept behind bars until her death after a number of in-custody incidents mostly for acting out.

Link:  The jury at the Ashley Smith inquest have released a list of 104 recommendations for how the Canadian prison system can better deal with mentally ill female inmates.

Additional video: News conference by Smith family lawyers: