Flu needle or inhaler?

Summer isn’t over yet, but now is the time to start thinking about flu vaccinations for your kids. There are two options, the flu shot and a nasal spray vaccine, but the Centres for Disease Control, says they are no longer recommending the spray because it doesn’t do a good job protecting people. However, a study by McMaster University researchers found that contrary to those recent reports, the flu nasal spray provides the same protection as a standard shot.

The trial was conducted over a three year period by researchers from McMaster and what they found directly challenges recommendations from the Centres for Disease Control. Dr. Mark Loeb and his team travelled to Hutterite colonies in Western Canada. They randomly assigned nearly 1200 children with either the spray or the shot. The results are not consistent with the CDC’s findings.

“In contrast to what had been previously reported, they both were pretty equal. In other words, the nasal spray protected not better and not worse than the shot in the arm.”

Dr. Loeb says their results will be passed along to the Centre for Disease Control and the findings will be used to help make future decisions on influenza vaccinations.

“They said their recommendation not to use the nasal spray was interim so they are going to be looking at data from all over the world including our trial.”

But at least until the fall of 2017, the CDC will maintain their stance against a needle-free vaccination program.


Commenting Guidelines

  • Comments are open for 2 days only after publication of article
  • All comments subject to approval
    • Comments must be constructive and a minimum of 5 words
    • Please do not submit multiple identical comments
    • Personal attacks will not be posted
    • We reserve the right to edit submissions for spelling, grammar, and language
  • CH-CHing! points will be awarded upon submission, however comments will not appear live until they have been approved
  • During the approval process, we reserve the right to withdraw CH-CHing! points awarded to you for comments that do not meet the above guidelines


Prettysmartgal says:

The sad thing about needles is that once it’s in your system, it’s there. If you have a bad reaction, you cannot get it out of your system as quickly as you would if it were a pill, etc.