Friday, March 29, 2024

Timer

Millard tries to have a mistrial declared in the Babcock murder trial

First Published:

Dellen Millard applied for a mistrial at the Laura Babcock murder trial today. He said his co-accused Mark Smich had changed his defence tactic in closing arguments to the jury and that surprise attack compromised his right to a fair trial.  Justice Michael Code did not agree.

Millard says that during pre-trial arguments in June, he and his co-accused Mark Smich agreed not to have antagonistic defence tactics and Millard said he conducted his whole defence with that understanding. In Mark Smich’s lawyer’s closing address, Tom Dungey told the jury that if they believed Laura Babcock was dead, they should look at the evidence against Millard and find that he was the more culpable of the two accused. Millard called this an unfair ambush.

Justice Code said it was obvious that if the jury was likely to believe Laura Babcock was indeed dead, then Mark Smich’s lawyer would remind the jury about the evidence the crown presented.

“Did you really expect Mr. Dungey not to point out to the jury that the preponderance of evidence points to you?” the judge asked Millard.

Mark Smich could have testified against Millard from the stand, like he did at the Bosma trial, the judge reminded Millard.

“There were 101 things I could have said about Mr. Smich but I did not do that.”

Millard argued and the judge said that was wise of Millard because it could have provoked Smich to testify, instead he said all we have is the crown’s evidence, which Millard has known about for years.

“I’ve beaten you up badly in oral arguments,” the judge told Millard. “Which is what happens when you make a weak argument.”

The motion was dismissed and the jury continues to deliberate. They have been at it since about 2 pm Tuesday.

More Top News

Ontario school boards suing TikTok, Meta, and Snapchat

Four of Ontario's largest school boards are suing the parent companies of Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, and TikTok. The boards are alleging the social media platforms...

Evening weather forecast for March 28, 2024

Shelly Marriage shares the forecast for March 28, 2024 and the days ahead.

Experts warn drivers to be careful on eclipse day

Researchers from Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre in Toronto are warning drivers to beware in the hours before and after the big solar eclipse on...

Premier Ford rejects Ottawa’s bill of rights and protection funds for tenants

Premier Doug Ford is going along with the Quebec government in rejecting Ottawa's attempt to help renters. On Wednesday, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau gave...

Hamilton mayor intends to use strong mayor powers for affordable housing

Residents and businesses near two Stoney Creek parking lots are disappointed after Hamilton mayor Andrea Horwath decided to use her strong mayor powers to...

Date set for inquest into death of man during Halton police shootout in 2018

A provincial coroner has set a date for an inquest into a man's death after a shootout with Halton police almost six years ago. Ahmadu...